Australian consumers only : USA & World enquires & information visit spicoatings.com - Authorised Australian & New Zealand Distributor

Surface Behaviour vs Internal Insulation

Cool Surfaces | Environment | Passive House | Sustainability | Urban Heat Solutions

A Performance Comparison That Actually Matters

The insulation industry has trained everyone to think from the inside out.

R-values. Bulk batts. Thickness. Trapped air.

But solar heat does not start inside a building.
It starts at the surface.

If you want performance, you need to understand the difference between surface behaviour control and internal insulation resistance.


1. Where Heat Actually Enters

Solar energy hitting a roof is made up of:

  • 44% visible light
  • 53% near infrared
  • 3% ultraviolet

Reference:
NASA Earth Observatory – Solar Radiation Basics
https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/features/EnergyBalance

Most of that energy is infrared. That is the heat load.

If the surface absorbs it, the substrate temperature rises dramatically.
Once that happens, internal insulation is reacting to stored heat, not preventing it.

That is a big difference.


2. Internal Insulation: How It Works

Bulk insulation works by resisting conductive heat transfer. It traps air. It slows heat flow.

Standards like AS/NZS 4859.1 and ASTM C518 measure conductivity and thermal resistance under controlled conditions.

ASTM C518 – Standard Test Method for Steady-State Thermal Transmission Properties
https://www.astm.org/c0518

The problem is this:

  • It is measured in steady-state lab conditions
  • It assumes heat has already entered the structure
  • It does not account for dynamic solar radiation load

Internal insulation reduces the rate of heat moving inside.
It does not stop the surface from overheating.

That is why roof cavities can exceed 60°C to 80°C in Australian summer conditions.

CSIRO guidance on roof space temperatures:
https://www.csiro.au/en/research/environmental-impacts/climate-change/climate-adaptation/keeping-homes-cool

By the time heat reaches the insulation layer, the damage is done.


3. Surface Behaviour: A Different Control Mechanism

Surface behaviour focuses on three core physics principles:

  • Reflectance
  • Emissivity
  • Thermal diffusivity

Reflectance prevents absorption.
Emissivity releases residual heat.
Low diffusivity prevents rapid heat migration into the substrate.

This is not about slowing heat inside a wall.
It is about stopping heat loading at the envelope.

Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory research on cool surfaces confirms the importance of solar reflectance and thermal emittance in reducing roof temperature.

LBNL Heat Island Group – Cool Roofs Overview
https://heatisland.lbl.gov/coolscience/cool-roofs

But most reflective paints rely primarily on reflectance alone.

High reflectance without controlled diffusivity still allows substrate heat gain.

That is where surface science separates coatings from insulation systems.


4. Performance in Real Conditions

Field performance matters more than lab theory.

The City of Adelaide Cool Roof Trial recorded internal temperature reductions of up to 6°C when using Super Therm®.

City of Adelaide Cool Roof Trial summary:
https://neotechcoatings.com/super-therm-testing-and-results/

The dry film thickness was only 0.25 mm.

That matters.

At 250 microns, the coating is not adding R-value in the traditional sense.
It is controlling surface heat load through reflectivity, emissivity and low thermal diffusivity.

ASTM E1461 testing confirms low thermal diffusivity values in thin materials.

ASTM E1461 – Thermal Diffusivity by Flash Method
https://www.astm.org/e1461

When heat cannot rapidly diffuse into the substrate, internal temperature stabilises.

Internal insulation cannot do that because it is not at the point of impact.


5. Summer vs Winter Performance

One of the biggest misconceptions is that reflective systems only work in summer.

Surface behaviour coatings that balance reflectance and emissivity can reduce peak heat gain in summer while moderating rapid radiative cooling at night.

Princeton research into radiative heat transfer differences between sky cooling and ground-level IR exchange highlights how infrared behaviour varies by wavelength and environment.

Princeton Engineering – Radiative Cooling Research
https://engineering.princeton.edu/news/2019/10/03/scientists-find-new-way-keep-buildings-cool-without-electricity

Internal insulation cannot respond to this dynamic surface exchange.

It is passive resistance.
Surface science is active control without energy use.


6. Where Each System Wins

Be realistic.

Internal insulation is essential in cold climates for conductive heat loss reduction.
It is effective in walls and ceilings where solar radiation is not directly striking.

Surface behaviour control is critical in:

  • Metal roofs
  • Containers
  • Industrial sheds
  • Infrastructure exposed to full solar load
  • Buildings in high solar intensity regions

In high radiation climates like Australia, the surface becomes the battleground.

If you do not manage that, you are constantly fighting stored heat.


7. The Performance Hierarchy

Here is the practical order of control:

  1. Block solar radiation at the surface
  2. Minimise heat diffusion into the substrate
  3. Control emissive release
  4. Then rely on internal insulation

Most buildings reverse this order.

That is inefficient.

Surface behaviour coatings like Super Therm® are designed to block 96.1% of total solar heat and reflect 97% of UV, with 99% infrared blocking performance verified through ASTM testing.

More detailed performance data:
https://neotechcoatings.com/coating-products/super-therm-solar-heat-block-coating/

This is not a paint claim.
It is surface heat load management.


Final Comparison

FactorInternal InsulationSurface Behaviour Coating
LocationInside cavityAt heat impact point
MechanismResist conductionBlock radiation + control diffusion
Solar IR ControlNoYes
Dynamic PerformanceLimitedHigh
Thickness Required50–200 mm0.25 mm dry film
Heat Storage in SubstrateHighMinimal

Internal insulation slows heat movement.
Surface behaviour reduces heat existence in the first place.

If you are designing for thermal resilience in high solar regions, surface control is not optional.

It is fundamental.


References

NASA Earth Observatory – Solar Energy Balance
https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/features/EnergyBalance

ASTM C518 – Thermal Transmission Properties
https://www.astm.org/c0518

ASTM E1461 – Thermal Diffusivity
https://www.astm.org/e1461

LBNL Heat Island Group – Cool Roof Science
https://heatisland.lbl.gov/coolscience/cool-roofs

Princeton Radiative Cooling Research
https://engineering.princeton.edu/news/2019/10/03/scientists-find-new-way-keep-buildings-cool-without-electricity

Super Therm® Testing and Results
https://neotechcoatings.com/super-therm-testing-and-results/

Super Therm® Product Page
https://neotechcoatings.com/coating-products/super-therm-solar-heat-block-coating/


Looking to join one of the world’s leading coatings companies. Contact us if you’re a quality applicator looking for new products and markets!